Home / Buyer's guides / Impreza 2.5RS Sedan 4D

Subaru Impreza 2.5RS Sedan 4D buyer's guide

Subaru Impreza 2.5RS Sedan 4D -- the model's own buyer's guide: variants, values and what to check.

Years listed: 1993-2005 ยท Series: Impreza

Overview and history

The Subaru Impreza is the car that turned all-wheel drive from a winter-weather curiosity into the default answer for a whole generation of American buyers โ€” and, in its first two generations, the car that made Subaru matter to enthusiasts. Launched in Japan in late 1992 and sold in the United States from the 1993 model year, the Impreza replaced the ageing Loyale as Subaru's compact, and it did so with a formula no rival offered at the price: a flat-four engine mounted longitudinally, a proper centre differential, and all four wheels driven, all the time, in every trim from the cheapest Brighton coupe to the rally-bred 2.5RS.

Be explicit about scope before anything else, because "Impreza" covers a lot of metal and this guide covers only part of it. The cars filed here are thirteen, all offered for sale, in exactly two generations. Five are first-generation cars on the GC/GM/GF chassis, 1993 to 1999 in this pool โ€” a 1993 wagon, a 1996 Brighton coupe, a 1997 sedan, a 1998 2.5RS coupe and a 1999 L sedan. Eight are second-generation GD/GG cars from 2002 to 2005 โ€” two 2002 cars including an RS wagon, a 2004 2.5TS Sport Wagon, and five 2005 cars headed by the 2.5RS sedan. There are no turbocharged WRX or STI cars in this pool, and no third-generation (2008-on) or later cars at all. That is not a gap in the guide; it is the shape of the market as filed. What follows is a buyer's guide to the naturally aspirated first- and second-generation Impreza, with the turbo cars discussed only where you need to understand them to avoid paying for one you are not getting.

That focus is where the interesting buying is. The first-generation Impreza โ€” GC sedan, GM coupe, GF wagon โ€” was designed under the shadow of Subaru's rally programme: the World Rally Car that McRae, Burns and Solberg made famous was this shell, and the road car shares its architecture, with the EJ flat-four low in the nose, symmetrical all-wheel drive, strut suspension at both ends and a boxy shell with thin pillars and excellent visibility. In America it arrived as worthy transport โ€” front-wheel drive was still offered on the earliest, cheapest cars โ€” until, for 1998, Subaru of America gave enthusiasts the 2.5RS: the big 2.5-litre engine, bonnet scoop and vents, a deep bumper with large fog lamps, and gold wheels on the first year's cars. America never got the contemporary Japanese WRX or STI in this shell; the 2.5RS was the substitute, sold for only four model years, 1998 to 2001, and it has become the collectable GC โ€” the centre of gravity of this pool.

The second generation, launched for 2002 in the United States, is the car nicknamed the "bugeye" for its round headlamps. It is bigger, heavier, substantially stiffer โ€” Subaru quoted a torsional rigidity improvement of more than half over the GC โ€” and safer, and it finally brought the real WRX turbo to America. The naturally aspirated cars continued underneath it as the 2.5RS sedan and 2.5TS wagon, facelifted for 2005. The five 2005 cars in this pool are that facelifted GD in its last naturally aspirated RS form, before the badge gave way to the 2.5i for 2006: newer, easier to live with and, in the market's eyes, less romantic than the GC โ€” which is precisely why they can be the smarter buy.

Why buy one now? The driving experience is genuinely distinct โ€” no other affordable classic combines a low flat-four's centre of gravity, full-time all-wheel drive and steering that talks through a hydraulic rack โ€” and the mechanicals are honest and well understood, the EJ family's strengths and its one notorious weakness (head gaskets on the 2.5-litre cars) documented to the last torque figure. These were working cars, bought for snow-belt states, and the survivors divide sharply into cherished enthusiast cars and worn-out winter beaters. The pool reflects that geography: Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Ohio, Vermont and Rhode Island feature heavily, with single cars from Texas, Florida, Washington and Virginia. A New England car has lived in road salt; a Texas or Florida car has lived in heat. You inspect for the life the car has actually had. Every car here is a private Marketplace listing, seven manual and six automatic โ€” a manual majority that tells you enthusiasts are now on both sides of these sales, which is the best and the worst thing that can happen to a twenty-five-year-old Subaru.

A 1998 Subaru Impreza 2.5RS Coupe 2D in Black, photographed in Taunton, MA
The car this market revolves around: a 1998 2.5RS coupe in Black, from Taunton, Massachusetts. The first-year RS cues are all in this one photograph if the car is correct โ€” coupe shell, deep front bumper, bonnet scoop and vents. A New England car, so read the caption the other way too: everything the rust section says about rear arches and subframes applies with full force.
A 2005 Subaru Impreza 2.5RS Sedan 4D in White, photographed in Bethlehem, PA
The other pole of the pool: a 2005 2.5RS sedan in White, from Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. The facelifted GD is bigger, stiffer and safer than the GC coupe above, and carries the same 165 hp flat-four idea seven years on. Pennsylvania salt applies here too โ€” newer does not mean exempt from the underside checks.

The models

Every Impreza here is built the same way underneath: unitary steel shell, longitudinal flat-four, all-wheel drive (with the early front-wheel-drive exception flagged below), MacPherson struts at both ends, and a wagon, sedan or coupe body. What the badge changes is engine size, trim โ€” and, on the RS, the entire intent of the car.

ModelYearsEngineOutputBuiltCharacter
Brighton1995โ€“19971.8 flat-four (EJ18), later 2.2 (EJ22)110โ€“137 hpVolume trim, no separate count publishedThe stripper; lightest, simplest, cheapest when new
L / LX1993โ€“20012.2 flat-four (EJ22)135โ€“142 hpThe bulk of GC productionThe honest workhorse; the pool's 1999 L is one
Outback Sport1995โ€“20012.2 (EJ22), later 2.5 (EJ251)137โ€“165 hpVolume trim, no separate count publishedRaised, two-tone wagon; the crossover before the word
2.5RS coupe1998โ€“20012.5 flat-four (EJ25D, then EJ251)165 hpLow thousands per year for the USThe collectable GC; rally dress, no turbo
2.5RS sedan2000โ€“20012.5 flat-four (EJ251)165 hpLow thousands per year for the USThe coupe's mechanical twin with four doors
2.5RS (GD)2002โ€“20052.5 flat-four (EJ251, then EJ253)165 hpVolume performance trimThe bugeye/blobeye NA flagship; the pool's core
2.5TS Sport Wagon2002โ€“20042.5 flat-four (EJ251/EJ253)165 hpVolume trimThe RS engine in the GG wagon shell
WRX (GD, context)2002โ€“20052.0 turbo flat-four (EJ205)227 hpVolume performance trimNot in this pool โ€” know it to avoid badge swaps

(Outputs are period US SAE figures. Subaru never published clean per-trim US production splits for the Brighton, L and Outback Sport, so this table does not invent them; the 2.5RS was a low-volume car, a few thousand a year at most โ€” the fact that matters for values.)

The Brighton. The Brighton was the price leader. Early cars carry the 1.8-litre EJ18; later cars, including the period of the red 1996 coupe in this pool, moved to the 2.2. Equipment was sparse โ€” manual windows, minimal trim, no tachometer on the earliest cars โ€” and the first cars were front-wheel drive rather than all-wheel drive: check any Brighton (and any 1993โ€“95 base car) for a driven rear axle before assuming AWD, because a front-drive Impreza is a different and far less desirable car. In return you get lightness and simplicity, and a sound Brighton coupe is now bought as a shell โ€” a rust-free starting point for a swap โ€” as often as for transport.

The L and LX. The L was the volume Impreza, and the 2.2-litre EJ22 under its bonnet is the most reliable engine Subaru built in this period, as the engines section makes in full. Sedans, coupes and wagons were offered; the LX added equipment, not performance. The pool's 1999 L sedan in Tan, from Topton, Pennsylvania, is the archetype: Phase II EJ22, standard all-wheel drive by then, no RS theatre. Buy an L on condition alone โ€” nobody restores or fakes them, and a good one is the cheapest honest entry into GC ownership.

The wagon and the Outback Sport. The GF wagon is the most practical GC โ€” same footprint as the sedan, genuinely useful load bay โ€” and the pool opens with one: a white 1993 wagon from Richmond, Virginia, a first-year car. The Outback Sport (from 1995) added raised suspension, two-tone paint and cladding to the same wagon; the cladding traps mud against the rear arches and sills, so its rust checks need the trim edges lifted and a torch, not a glance.

The 2.5RS, GC and GM (1998โ€“2001). This is the car. Subaru of America took the coupe shell (the sedan followed for 2000), fitted the DOHC EJ25D for 1998 and the SOHC EJ251 from 1999, and dressed it as the rally car America could not otherwise buy: bonnet scoop (non-functional โ€” it feeds nothing, there being no intercooler), bonnet vents, a deep front bumper with large fog lamps, side skirts, a rear spoiler โ€” tall on the coupe, lower on the sedan โ€” and five-spoke alloys, gold on the 1998 cars, silver thereafter. Inside: chequered cloth sports seats, a leather-wrapped wheel and, on most coupes, a sunroof. The suspension was firmed, the brakes enlarged, and a viscous limited-slip rear differential arrived for 2000โ€“2001. It is not fast by modern standards โ€” 165 hp moving roughly 1,250 kg โ€” but the gearing is short, the steering quick, and the car feels keyed-up in a way the ordinary Impreza does not. The pool's black 1998 coupe from Taunton, Massachusetts is the first-year car and the most collectable of the thirteen.

The GD cars: 2.5RS and 2.5TS (2002โ€“2005). The second-generation naturally aspirated range is simpler. The sedan is the 2.5RS; the wagon is the 2.5TS Sport Wagon โ€” the pool's red 2004 car from North Providence, Rhode Island, and its silver 2002 RS wagon from Shenandoah, Pennsylvania, sit either side of a badge change (the wagon was sold under both names in this period, so judge the car, not the badge). All carry the 165 hp SOHC 2.5, all are all-wheel drive, manual or four-speed automatic. The GD shell is roomier, the interior a step up, the safety equipment modern for its day โ€” and the car is roughly 150 kg heavier than the GC, which you feel in the steering's first few degrees. The five 2005 facelift cars in this pool add revised lamps and bumpers, a smarter cabin and drive-by-wire throttle โ€” a running change that matters at inspection, because throttle faults on a 2005 car are electronic first and mechanical second.

The cars that are not here โ€” and why they matter. The WRX (2002-on, 227 hp EJ205 turbo) and the STI (2004-on in the US, 300 hp) are not in this pool, and the GC WRX and STI were never sold new in America at all. They matter because badges, bonnets and bumpers swap freely across the range, and a dressed-up RS wearing WRX or STI badges is a staple of the classifieds. The rule is simple: an Impreza in this territory is a naturally aspirated car until the engine bay proves otherwise. A turbo car has an intercooler on top of the engine and a turbocharger low at the back of the bay; an RS has none of it, whatever the boot lid says. Price the car in front of you, never the badge on it.

A 1996 Subaru Impreza Brighton Coupe 2D in Red, photographed in Crawfordville, FL
The other end of the GC range from the RS: a 1996 Brighton coupe in Red, from Crawfordville, Florida. Same coupe shell, stripper trim, small engine โ€” and a Florida life, which swaps the northern rust questions for heat, sun and air-conditioning questions. As a shell, a straight Brighton is exactly what swap builders hunt for.
A 2004 Subaru Impreza 2.5TS Sport Wagon 4D in Red, photographed in North Providence, RI
A 2004 2.5TS Sport Wagon in Red, from North Providence, Rhode Island โ€” the RS engine in the practical GG wagon body. Rhode Island winters mean the rear-arch and subframe checks in the rust section are not optional on this car, however clean the top side photographs.

Engines and gearboxes

The small fours: EJ18 and EJ22

All Impreza engines belong to one family, the EJ: an all-alloy flat-four, belt-driven cams, cylinders laid flat in pairs either side of the crank. The layout is the car's character โ€” it sits low, keeps the centre of gravity down by the sills, and leaves the bay oddly empty-looking. It also means two heads, two head gaskets, and spark plugs sitting low on the sides of the engine pointing at the chassis rails: plug changes on a 2.5 are fiddly enough that skipped plug services are common, and fresh plugs with old, oil-fouled leads are a tell.

The EJ18 (1.8 litres, 110 hp) powered the earliest base and Brighton cars: SOHC, understressed to the point of indestructibility, and slow โ€” with almost nothing to wear out expensively. The EJ22 (2.2 litres, 135โ€“142 hp) is the engine this guide would put in a museum. Also SOHC and simple, it earned its reputation as the Subaru engine that simply does not fail: head gaskets are a non-issue by EJ standards, the bottom end is strong, and 250,000 miles on oil changes alone is a documented, ordinary outcome. If you are buying an ordinary GC for transport, an EJ22 car is the rational peak of the range, and its inspection is mostly a formality: seal and rocker-cover oil leaks, a belt due by age, a steady warm idle. Budget a full belt service โ€” belt, idlers, tensioner and water pump, roughly $700โ€“1,200 at an independent โ€” on any car without a dated invoice, and the EJ22 will repay you by needing nothing else.

All of these engines drive their cams with a toothed belt โ€” the family's one scheduled act of faith. Subaru's interval settled at 105,000 miles or 105 months for the later cars, shorter on the earliest; treat any undocumented belt as overdue, because age kills belts in cars that sit. The later 2.5s are interference designs where a snapped belt bends valves; the early 2.2 is famously forgiving โ€” but never buy on that distinction. The belt service is also the moment to renew the water pump, idlers and hydraulic tensioner, because the labour is the same and a seized idler takes the new belt with it. A belt invoice listing pump and idlers, not just a belt, marks a seller who maintained the car the way these cars need.

The 2.5s: EJ25D, EJ251 and EJ253

The 2.5-litre cars are the ones this market prices, and they come in two distinct flavours that you must be able to tell apart, because their famous fault presents differently in each.

The EJ25D (1998 2.5RS, and the contemporary Legacy range) is a double-overhead-cam engine, 165 hp, and the keenest-feeling naturally aspirated EJ of the period โ€” it revs more freely than the SOHC cars and sounds harder doing it. It is also the engine with the serious head-gasket reputation. The Phase I gasket fails internally: combustion pressure and coolant cross between the water jacket and the cylinder or oilways, presenting as overheating that comes and goes, bubbles in the expansion tank with the engine running, coolant that disappears without a visible leak, a sweet-smelling exhaust, and oil and coolant contaminating each other. An EJ25D car that has not had its gaskets done should be priced as one that will need them โ€” both heads, checked and skimmed as required, with a full belt service folded in, at roughly $1,800โ€“3,000 at an independent specialist. Done properly with the later multi-layer steel gaskets, it is a once-in-the-car's-life repair; done cheaply with the heads unmeasured, it is a subscription.

The EJ251 and EJ253 (1999โ€“2005 RS and TS) are single-overhead-cam engines, still 165 hp in these years, torquier at low revs and less theatrical at high ones. Their head-gasket failure is a different disease with the same name. The SOHC gaskets characteristically leak externally: coolant weeps from the gasket seam, most often at the back of the left-hand head, and oil seeps from the right-hand head, dripping onto the exhaust and announcing itself as a hot-oil smell after a run and a slow fall in the coolant level with crusty green or pink residue at the seam. External weeping can be monitored for a long time โ€” many cars run for years with a damp seam and a topped-up expansion tank โ€” but it does not heal, it worsens, and the endgame is the same overheating that kills the engine if the coolant runs low unnoticed. Budget the same $1,800โ€“3,000 job cost when the weep is active, and treat a dry-seamed, documented-gaskets SOHC car as worth a clear premium over a damp one. The test that distinguishes a weep from a spill is in the inspection: clean-looking coolant residue at the head seam, viewed from underneath with a torch, on the rear corners of both heads.

Two supporting points apply to every 2.5. First, overheating is the executioner: an EJ run hot warps its heads, turning a gasket job into an engine โ€” so a history of overheating, a hurriedly fitted new radiator, or a thermostat removed "to help it run cool" outrank the gasket question itself. Ask directly whether the car has ever overheated, and watch the gauge on the test drive; the needle should rise to the middle and stay there. Second, cooling systems age regardless of the car's year: plastic radiator end tanks crack at the neck, and a full refresh โ€” radiator, hoses, thermostat, cap โ€” is roughly $400โ€“800 and belongs in any recommissioning budget. Oil consumption deserves a calm word too: a quart between services on a high-mileage EJ is ordinary, a quart every thousand miles is wear โ€” stem seals if it smokes at start-up after sitting, rings if it smokes under load. Check the level before the test drive and again after.

The turbo cars, in one paragraph

You are not buying one from this pool, but you need the vocabulary. The GD WRX uses the EJ205, a 2.0-litre DOHC turbo making 227 hp, with a top-mount intercooler under a functional scoop; the STI uses the 2.5-litre EJ257 at 300 hp. Their failure modes are a different guide. Here they matter only as donor fashion: RS cars wear their wheels, wings and badges, and listings occasionally use "WRX" as a trim word for a car with none of the hardware. The engine bay settles it in five seconds: intercooler and turbo plumbing, or not.

Gearboxes and the all-wheel-drive system

The five-speed manual (the TY75/TY754 family) is the enthusiast's box and the majority fitment here, seven cars to six. A split-case design, light in action, with synchromesh that wears honestly: second gear crunches first, and a box that crunches second on a gentle, warm change is pricing a rebuild at roughly $1,200โ€“2,500 fitted. Test the clutch by bite point (high is worn), judder on take-up, and slip in a high gear at full throttle up a hill. A clutch is roughly $800โ€“1,400 fitted, and the rear main seal and the plastic separator plate behind the flywheel โ€” a known EJ oil-leak source, replaced with the later steel plate โ€” should be renewed while the box is out, for parts money only.

The manual car's centre differential is a viscous coupling: sealed, maintenance-free, and killed by mismatched tyres. That is a Subaru commandment across this whole guide โ€” all four tyres must match in make, size and wear โ€” because a viscous diff compensating for different rolling radii cooks itself, presenting as binding and tyre-scrubbing on full-lock turns. Price a viscous unit fitted at roughly $600โ€“1,200, and walk every car in a tight circle on the viewing.

The four-speed automatic (4EAT) is a strong, conventional torque-converter box, and the six automatic cars in this pool should not be dismissed โ€” an automatic L or TS wagon is a perfectly rational winter car. Its all-wheel drive works differently: an electronically controlled multi-plate clutch pack (Subaru's MPT system) varies the front-to-rear split continuously, defaulting to front-biased and locking up as slip is detected. Faults are usually electrical or neglect: harsh or flaring changes on tired fluid, a flashing warning light for a stored code, and transfer-clutch shudder on tight turns โ€” the automatic's version of binding, cured first with fresh fluid before anyone condemns the clutch pack. A fluid-and-filter service is roughly $200โ€“350; a rebuilt box is $2,000โ€“3,500 fitted, which is why an automatic with no fluid history gets priced down. Note the automatic car has two dipsticks โ€” ATF and front-differential gear oil โ€” and filling the wrong one is a classic home-mechanic disaster whose results you may be viewing.

Driveshafts, CV joints and wheel bearings complete the driveline. Clicking on full lock is an outer CV joint; a drone rising with road speed and changing with steering load is a wheel bearing โ€” a known GD wear item, pressed into the hub, roughly $250โ€“450 a corner fitted. A car that drives straight, quiet and bind-free on full lock has passed the driveline's whole examination in five minutes.

Problem areas

Everything in this section follows from where these cars lived and what they were bought to do. An Impreza was the winter car, the ski car โ€” the pool's geography, heavy with Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Ohio, Vermont and Rhode Island listings, is the model's geography. Salt is the first problem, the 2.5's head gaskets the second, and deferred servicing on a car that was cheap for a decade the third. Almost everything else is ordinary old-car wear at ordinary prices; the bad news is that rust attacks these cars' structure in places a quick walk-around never shows you.

Rust: the map

Rust on a GC or GD Impreza follows the salt spray and the mud traps, and it is markedly worse on the first-generation cars, whose rustproofing was period Japanese โ€” which is to say, optimistic. Work through it in this order, because the order is the order in which rust writes the car off.

Rear wheel arches and quarter panels. The signature GC rot spot, and the first place to look. The arch lip traps mud and salt against the folded seam where outer quarter meets inner arch, and the panel rusts from the seam outward: bubbles along the arch edge, then perforation, then a quarter that needs cutting. Wagons and sedans suffer alike; Outback Sport cladding hides the early stages entirely. Press along the lip, view the seam from inside the boot or load bay where you can, and price honestly โ€” new arch metal cut in, welded and painted runs roughly $800โ€“2,000 a side, while filler over bubbles is worth nothing and returns within a winter. GD arches are better protected but the same seam exists; a rust-free GD arch is one of the newer cars' clearest condition signals.

Sills and jacking points. The sills carry the jack, and on a salt-belt car they fill from the drain holes up. Check the full length, front to back, with particular attention to the rear ends ahead of the rear wheels, where spray concentrates. Surface scabbing on the sill's outer face is cosmetic; softness, holed pinch welds or a jacking point that flexes when you press it hard is structural. Sill work, cut out and replaced with paint, is roughly $600โ€“1,500 a side โ€” but sills rarely rot alone on a GC, and sill rust plus arch rust plus the next item is the combination that makes a car a parts car wearing a price tag.

Front and rear subframes. The GD's particular trap, and a GC weakness too. The subframes are pressed-steel cradles carrying the suspension, sitting in the direct line of road spray, and they corrode from the inside and the mounting faces outward. A New England GD's rear subframe can look merely scruffy and be thin enough to flex at its mounts; the front cradle rots around its mounting points. Neither is ever visible in listing photographs. On a lift, prod both subframes along their full length and around every mount; a replacement rear subframe with the labour and the seized bolts that will snap runs roughly $800โ€“1,800 fitted, alignment afterwards not optional. A holed subframe is not a bargain until that number is in the negotiation.

The underside generally. Floor pans hold up better than the appendages, but check the seams and seat mounting points, and anywhere a previous owner has jacked the car by the floor โ€” a torn floor seam is a water inlet. The steel fuel-filler pipe corrodes in the mud trap behind the right-hand rear wheel, presenting as a fuel smell after filling; replacement is roughly $250โ€“500 fitted, a job almost every salt-belt GC needs or has had. Brake and fuel pipes along the floor deserve the same torch pass: corroded brake pipes are a safety item and a bargaining point at roughly $400โ€“900 made and fitted, and no car with flaking, pitted pipes should be driven home on faith.

The smaller traps. Door bottoms (drain holes block, the door fills, the seam bubbles), the bonnet's leading edge on GD cars, the windscreen surround where a badly fitted replacement screen scratched the paint, the spare-wheel well on wagons, and the battery tray. None alone kills a car; together they are the biography of its winters, and they cross-check the seller's story โ€” a car described as garaged and summer-only that shows scabbed arches and a thin rear subframe has been described by someone else.

A note on underseal, because these cars attract it: factory protection is thin and patchy after twenty-five years, while a fresh, uniform coat of black stone-chip over subframes, sills and floor on a car sold in winter is a question, not an answer. Prod through it at the known spots; if the seller resists the prod, you have your answer.

Engine: head gaskets, belts and the supporting cast

The engines section laid out the two head-gasket diseases โ€” the EJ25D's internal failure and the EJ251/EJ253's external weep โ€” and this section prices the neglect around them. The pattern is a cascade: a weeping SOHC car gets topped up instead of repaired, the level drops once too often, the engine overheats once, and the gasket job becomes a warped-heads job becomes an engine. Finding an active weep means pricing where the car sits on that cascade; the evidence is the radiator's age, the coolant's colour and level, and whether the expansion tank carries tide marks of repeated low running. A car with a new radiator, a missing thermostat and a shrug is a different risk from one whose owner can show a level that never dropped.

Around the gaskets, the EJ's supporting cast wears predictably. Timing-belt idlers and tensioners grow noisy before they fail and are renewed with the belt as a matter of course; a belt invoice listing only a belt is half a job. Water pumps weep from the tell-tale hole. Crank and cam seals harden and leak onto the belt covers, and rocker-cover and spark-plug tube seals leak oil into the plug tubes, where it cooks the leads and causes the misfire-under-load owners chase through the ignition for months. The cure for the cluster is one: the belt service done completely, with seals โ€” roughly $900โ€“1,500 all-in โ€” which is why a recent, itemised belt invoice is the most valuable paper in a 2.5's file. The plastic separator plate behind the flywheel cracks and leaks oil that mimics a rear-main-seal failure; the plate is cheap, the gearbox-out access is the cost at roughly $700โ€“1,200 of labour, and any car that has had a clutch should have the later steel plate โ€” ask. Idle-air valves gum up and hunt; airflow sensors drift and cause flat spots; knock sensors crack and light the lamp for roughly $150โ€“300 fitted. None of it is exotic; all of it separates a serviced car from a merely fuelled one.

Catalytic converters are the GD's growing expense: a dying converter lights the lamp with the efficiency code every Subaru forum knows, and the honest repair โ€” a quality converter, not a spacer or a delete โ€” runs roughly $600โ€“1,200 fitted. A lamp that does not light with the ignition has been taped or removed, and that seller is telling you something.

Suspension, steering, brakes and driveline

The strut suspension's wear items are the universal ones, sharpened by all-wheel drive loadings and salt. Front lower-arm rear bushes tear, giving a knock and a wandering feel under braking. Drop links rattle over broken surfaces โ€” roughly $100โ€“250 a pair fitted, and the noise most often mis-sold as "needs struts". Struts tire by 120,000 miles; a car that crashes over ridges and floats over crests needs a set at roughly $800โ€“1,600 for four fitted with an alignment. Springs snap at the pigtail ends in salt country, announced by a bang in the night and a low corner. Ball joints and track-rod ends show as play at the wheel rim, checked jacked, rocking at quarter-to-three and twelve-to-six.

The hydraulic steering is one of the cars' pleasures โ€” check the fluid (dark and burnt-smelling is old), the pump (a groan on lock is wear or low fluid, not character) and the rack boots (split boots let grit eat the seals; a leaking rack is roughly $500โ€“1,000 exchange fitted). Brakes are front discs with rear discs on RS cars and drums on many L and Brighton cars โ€” adequate and cheaper to keep. The system's enemy is standing still: callipers seize, sliders stick, discs rust-band, and a stored car needs the full hydraulic once-over at roughly $600โ€“1,400. A handbrake that barely holds on a slope is a priced job, not a quirk. Add the exhaust: the EJ's unequal-length manifolds give the offbeat burble, the system rots from the back box forward, and a full standard system is roughly $500โ€“1,100 fitted. A loud aftermarket system tells you the previous owner's priorities; a car returned to standard for sale, fresh clamps on old flanges, tells you the same thing more quietly.

Interior, electrics and body fittings

Subaru interiors of this period are durable in the way agricultural equipment is durable: hard plastics, honest cloth, switches that outlast the car. The wear that prices a car is specific. The driver's bolster wears through on RS chequered cloth and the foam beneath collapses; RS cloth is not reproduced, so a good seat set is worth money โ€” allow roughly $300โ€“700 for a used set or a one-seat retrim. Sunroof cars (most RS coupes) suffer blocked drains that pour water into the headlining and A-pillars; check the headlining's front corners for tide marks, and price a dead roof at roughly $300โ€“800 to recommission.

Electrics fail at the edges: alternator bearings whine before the charge goes, starter solenoids click on hot restarts, window regulators slow and die, driver's first. Air conditioning on the Florida and Texas cars is a condition of use, not a luxury: a warm system needs diagnosis before gas, because a compressor is roughly $600โ€“1,100 fitted while a leak repair and recharge is a third of that โ€” a seller saying "just needs a recharge" is selling you the diagnosis he did not pay for. A sweet smell and a misting screen inside mean the heater matrix, a dashboard-out job at roughly $800โ€“1,500 and a walk-away-grade fault on a cheap car. Body fittings close the list: the GC's frameless door glass rattles when its guides wear, wagon rear wipers seize, wagon tailgate struts fail (usually onto your head during the viewing, which settles that question), and RS alloy wheels corrode at the bead, causing the slow puncture blamed on tyres โ€” budget roughly $75โ€“150 a wheel for refurbishment if the car is otherwise right.

A 1999 Subaru Impreza L Sedan 4D in Tan, photographed in Topton, PA
A 1999 Impreza L sedan in Tan, from Topton, Pennsylvania โ€” the EJ22 workhorse car, and the pool's best reminder that condition beats specification: an L with a dry underside and an itemised belt invoice is worth more, as transport, than an RS with bubbles on both arches.
A 1993 Subaru Impreza Wagon in White, photographed in Richmond, VA
The pool's first-year car: a 1993 Impreza wagon in White, from Richmond, Virginia. A 1993 car needs the front-wheel-drive question answered before anything else โ€” check that the rear wheels are driven โ€” and a Virginia life is kinder to the shell than the northern cars get.

How to inspect one

Allow a full hour, bring a torch, a tyre tread gauge, a magnet wrapped in cloth and a friend to work the pedals while you watch. Insist on a cold engine and, on any car you are serious about, a lift inspection before money changes hands โ€” on a salt-belt Impreza the underside is the car. Work in this order: walk-away faults first, haggling faults last.

  1. Paperwork and identity first. Match the VIN on the title to the plate at the base of the windscreen and the stamping in the engine bay. The chassis code tells you the shell (GC sedan, GM coupe, GF wagon, GD sedan, GG wagon) and the VIN's engine code tells you what the car left the factory with โ€” a car badged 2.5RS whose VIN says 2.2 is an L in costume. Ask for the belt invoice and any head-gasket invoice by name; on a 2.5, those two papers outweigh the service book's stamps.
  2. The lamp test and the cold start. Ignition on, before starting: check-engine, oil and charge lamps must all light โ€” a lamp that does not has been removed or taped, and the car gets priced as hiding a fault. Start from cold. A healthy EJ fires at once, idles high briefly, then settles. A light, diesel-like piston-slap rattle on a cold 2.5 that fades as it warms is a known, usually harmless trait; a rattle that stays is not. Watch the exhaust: vapour that clears is condensation; vapour that persists and smells sweet is coolant โ€” on an EJ25D, the internal gasket failure introducing itself.
  3. Coolant forensics. Cold, open the expansion tank: level between the marks, coolant clean and coloured, no oil film, no mayonnaise under the cap. Run the engine and watch for a steady stream of bubbles โ€” combustion gas in the water jacket, the EJ25D's signature. Squeeze the top hose as it warms; rock-hard within a minute of a cold start means combustion pressure, not heat. Then look underneath at the head seams: the SOHC weep shows first as crusty residue at the rear of the left-hand head.
  4. Under the car: rust, in the rust section's order. Lift or ramps, torch in hand: rear arch seams, sill lengths and jacking points, both subframes prod-tested around every mount, filler pipe, brake pipes, floor seams. Apply the underseal test as you go โ€” patchy and honest is factory; fresh and uniform is a question. Subframe or sill perforation ends the inspection until its cost is agreed in the price; arch bubbles are a negotiation; a holed filler pipe is a priced job.
  5. The belt and the leaks. Read the front of the engine: oil on the belt covers means cam or crank seals; oil in the plug tubes means tube seals and tired leads; a stain under the water pump is a weep with a date on it. Ask when belt, idlers, tensioner and pump were done, as one question โ€” a single date with an invoice is the job done; "the belt was done" is a third of it. No evidence, and the full belt service goes in your budget at the engines section's prices.
  6. Tyres: the all-wheel-drive examination. All four tyres must be the same make, model and size, with tread depths within a couple of millimetres of each other. Measure them โ€” do not eyeball them. Mismatched tyres on a manual car mean the viscous centre diff has been working overtime, and step 8 will tell you whether it survived. A brand-new pair on one axle with a worn pair on the other is the classic Impreza trap, freshly laid.
  7. The cold gearbox and clutch. On the manual, work through the gears at a standstill, then on the move: second-gear synchromesh, cold and warm, is the test โ€” a gentle change at moderate revs should drop in silently. Judge the clutch by bite point and by a full-throttle pull in a high gear up a hill; slip there is a clutch, priced with the separator plate done at the same time. On the automatic, check both dipsticks (gearbox and front differential), smell the ATF for burning, and drive for flare between changes and shudder on tight turns.
  8. The full-lock circle. In an empty car park, drive a full circle at walking pace on full lock, both ways. A manual car should roll smoothly; binding, winding-up and tyre scrub mean the centre diff is cooked or the tyres are mismatched โ€” the two causes separated by step 6's measurements. An automatic that shudders or drags on lock has transfer-clutch trouble. This five-minute test is the driveline's verdict, and a car that fails it gets priced with a differential in the bill.
  9. The test drive, fifteen minutes minimum. Include a climb, a fast road and a rough surface. The steering should be light, direct and free of groans on lock; the car should track and brake straight, and pull cleanly with no flat spot (airflow-meter or ignition-lead territory on these cars). Note the wheel-bearing drone and which corner direction silences it โ€” the bearing that goes quiet when unloaded is the worn one. Watch the temperature gauge throughout: middle and steady. Any climb toward the red reopens step 3 with a different ending.
  10. Heat, air conditioning and the sunroof. Whatever the season, run the heater full hot and check for a sweet smell or misting screen (the heater matrix), then run the air conditioning full cold on the southern cars โ€” cold air or a priced diagnosis, never "just a recharge". On a sunroof car, cycle the roof twice and check the headlining's front corners for water marks.
  11. Electrics and the interior, last but weighed. Work every window, the mirrors, the wagon's rear wiper, the heated rear screen, lights and washers. Sit in the driver's seat and judge bolster and foam with your weight, not your eyes; a collapsed seat is a retrim bill and a mileage witness. Check the boot or load bay for spare, jack and water in the well.
  12. Stance and the walk-around. Stand back, square-on, then down each flank: level stance, even arch gaps, no low corner (a snapped spring), no ripple (a repaired side). Run the magnet over arch lips, sill ends and lower doors. Then add up the jobs you have priced, out loud, with the seller โ€” on these cars the list, honestly made, is the negotiation.

Values

The figures that matter for this model are computed from this site's own listings and recorded sales, and they sit below this guide โ€” the listed-now summary and the market block are refreshed every time the site rebuilds, so use them rather than any number quoted elsewhere. What follows is how to read them, and it matters more than usual here, because the Impreza pool is small, all thirteen cars are offered for sale with none recorded as sold in the same set, and a small pool moves violently when a single exceptional or desperate car enters or leaves it. Read the range, never just the middle figure, and read any individual car against the condition spread described below rather than against the headline.

This is really three markets wearing one nameplate. At the top sits the GC 2.5RS, coupe above sedan, 1998 car above the rest โ€” priced on originality and shell condition in that order: correct engine, correct trim, unmodified suspension and unrotted rear quarters are what the premium buys, and a modified or rusty RS falls straight into the market below. In the middle sit the GD 2.5RS and 2.5TS cars โ€” newer, safer, more usable, priced as used cars rather than collectables, so mileage, belt and gasket evidence and subframe condition do the pricing; a documented GD is worth stretching for, because its buyer pool is deeper when you come to sell. At the base sit the ordinary GC cars โ€” L, Brighton, wagons โ€” priced as transport and shells: a rust-free Brighton coupe is worth real money to a swap builder and very little to anyone else, so the same car can be cheap and dear in the same week.

The condition spread is the widest fact here. The gap between a project and a sorted driver is not a percentage of value; on a 2.5 it is routinely the price of the car again, because the two big tickets โ€” head gaskets with a full belt service, and structural rust repair โ€” each cost a sum that does not care what the car cost to buy. The cheap cars at the bottom of any listing set share a biography (salt, storage, a weep ignored into an overheat), and the correct reading of a low asking figure on a northern 2.5 is not "bargain" but "which of the two big tickets is attached". Conversely, the premium for a car with both tickets already paid, invoices in hand, is the most rational money in this market โ€” you are buying work at a discount to its cost, fitted and proven.

Asking and achieved figures part company predictably. RS sellers ask with their hearts, anchored on the best result for the best car; cars actually change hands after the inspection list has been read aloud. Ordinary cars ask closer to their worth but sit longer, the buyer pool for a tan L sedan being thin even when the car is good. The negotiation currency is the same either way: the priced inspection list. Geography moves money too โ€” a genuinely rust-free southern or western shell commands its premium anywhere, because the northern buyer compares it not with northern cars but with the welding bill. And on the GC RS, originality is appreciating faster than condition alone, as modified cars are modified further and untouched cars disappear into collections.

Parts and ownership

The Impreza is one of the best-supported Japanese cars of its era: Subaru built the EJ package in enormous numbers across the Impreza, Legacy and Forester ranges, the factory still supplies a wide spread of parts, and the WRX enthusiast trade keeps specialists and breakers busy on the whole family's behalf. The naturally aspirated cars ride on that infrastructure โ€” with one warning: RS-specific trim is not infrastructure, and is priced like the low-production part it is.

Easy: service items of every kind โ€” filters, plugs, leads, belts, tensioners and water pumps are catalogue parts at ordinary prices, as are brake discs, pads, callipers and hoses, suspension bushes, drop links, ball joints and struts, wheel bearings, standard exhausts, CV joints, clutches, alternators, starters and radiators. Order today, fit this weekend. A full belt-service kit with pump and idlers is a few hundred in parts; the labour is the bill.

Harder and dearer: head-gasket work is a labour cost, not a parts problem โ€” the multi-layer steel gaskets are cheap, the heads-off day is not. GC body panels are the rising expense: sound rear quarters and arch sections, rust-free doors and wings, and unbroken RS front bumpers are breaker-hunted now, priced by scarcity. The 1998 RS's gold wheels in original finish, RS chequered cloth, coupe sunroof mechanisms and unbroken GC interior plastics sit in the same category. GD subframes are available new and used, but used ones come from the same salt that killed yours โ€” inspect a used subframe harder than you inspected the car. Heater matrices and air-conditioning compressors are available; their fitting labour is the cost.

Running costs. A sorted GC or GD Impreza is a realistic daily classic. Fuel consumption sits in the mid-to-high twenties per gallon on a run for the manuals, lower for the automatics; all-wheel drive exacts a small tax at the pump and a larger one in tyres, because the matched-set rule means a puncture at half-wear can mean four tyres rather than one โ€” budget for that moment, and rotate at every service so the set wears as a set. Servicing suits any competent independent, insurance is ordinary for ordinary cars and enthusiast-policy territory for a valued RS, and the car asks one discipline in return: oil and coolant levels checked monthly, because both of the EJ's famous failures announce themselves first as a level moving the wrong way. The budget line that catches new owners is the first year โ€” a deferred belt service, a matched set of tyres, brake hydraulics and small leaks honestly cost a four-figure sum before you improve anything, and recommissioning a stored car costs more again. Buy a car in regular use over a sleeping car at the same money, every time: the EJ forgives use and resents storage, and so does every seal, pipe and subframe on it.

A 1997 Subaru Impreza Sedan 4D in Blue, photographed in Alburgh, VT
A 1997 Impreza sedan in Blue, from Alburgh, Vermont โ€” as deep in snow country as this pool gets. A Vermont GC that still presents a straight flank and even stance has either lived a charmed life or been cared for properly; the underside, as always, casts the deciding vote.

Which one to buy

And the rule that overrides all of the above: buy the shell first and the specification second โ€” the least rusty car, with the belt and gasket evidence in writing, in the trim you can live with. Engines are rebuilt every week and gearboxes swapped every weekend. A rotten rear quarter, a holed subframe and a cooked centre differential are the three bills that turn a cheap Impreza into an expensive one โ€” and two of the three are written in the metal the car was born with, which no later money makes original again.

See the 13 Impreza 2.5RS Sedan 4D cars currently listed.