Home / Ford / Mustang Gen 1 / New York

Ford Mustang Gen 1 in New York for sale

12 for sale now · 0 previously sold in this exact combination.

Market Snapshot

Median asking (for sale now): $21,225 (n=12)

Median sold price by quarter — all Ford Mustang Gen 1 (this combination has too few dated sales for its own trend)

$47,013$32,738$18,4622021 Q1: $34,750 (n=42)2021 Q2: $35,500 (n=47)2021 Q3: $33,250 (n=65)2021 Q4: $42,000 (n=62)2022 Q1: $44,250 (n=69)2022 Q2: $42,500 (n=71)2022 Q3: $35,125 (n=86)2022 Q4: $40,250 (n=87)2023 Q1: $34,500 (n=54)2023 Q2: $42,250 (n=61)2023 Q3: $40,000 (n=79)2023 Q4: $36,500 (n=76)2024 Q1: $37,625 (n=46)2024 Q2: $32,750 (n=76)2024 Q3: $41,000 (n=109)2024 Q4: $35,000 (n=93)2025 Q1: $32,125 (n=56)2025 Q2: $40,625 (n=102)2025 Q3: $32,500 (n=114)2025 Q4: $34,500 (n=90)2026 Q1: $37,250 (n=65)2026 Q2: $39,625 (n=124)2026 Q3: $38,916 (n=125)2026 Q4: $35,500 (n=96)2021 Q12026 Q4Median asking now: $21,225

Medians of actual prices; call-for-price cars are excluded. Sold figures use dated sales only, each labeled with its sample size.

For sale now (12)

1971 Ford Mach 1 Mustang 351 M code$27,000 · 43% below typical
29,000 miles · Automatic · Green
Merrick, NY
SOURCE: Facebook
$27,000
43% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mach 1 Mustang 351 M code

Expand
Seller: Marketplace seller
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own Facebook Marketplace listing: Year: 1971; Mileage: 29000; Transmission: Automatic; Exterior Color: Green; Interior Color: Black; Vehicle Title: CLEAN.
Color: Green
1971 Ford Mustang$94,999 · 99% above typical
43,500 miles · Manual 4-Speed · Blue
West Seneca, NY
SOURCE: Dealer
$94,999
99% above the typical asking price for a Mustang

Expand
Seller: Online Auto Connection
Transmission: Manual 4-Speed
Condition: Mileage shown as 43,500. Transmission: Manual 4-Speed. Exterior: Blue. Interior: Black stock.
Color: Blue
1969 Ford Mustang GT 351 Convertible — Matching Numbers, Manual Transmission$18,950 · 34% below typical
Mileage not stated
College Point, NY
SOURCE: Facebook
$18,950
34% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang GT 351 Convertible — Matching Numbers, Manual Transmission

Expand
Seller: Marketplace seller
Condition: Listing details from the car's own Facebook Marketplace listing: Year: 1969.
1965 Ford Mustang Coupe 2D$15,000 · 33% below typical
78,000 miles · Automatic · Blue
Hopewell Junction, NY
SOURCE: Facebook
$15,000
33% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang Coupe 2D

Expand
Seller: Marketplace seller
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own Facebook Marketplace listing: Year: 1965; Mileage: 78000; Transmission: Automatic; Exterior Color: Blue; Interior Color: Black.
Color: Blue
1967 Ford Mustang$50,000 · 5% above typical
Mileage not stated · Manual · Red / black vinyl
Glens Falls, NY
SOURCE: Hemmings
$50,000
5% above the typical asking price for a Mustang

Expand
Seller: MAKE OFFER
Transmission: Manual
Color: Red / black vinyl
1966 Ford Mustang$22,450 · 53% below typical
50,050 miles · Manual · Red
Setauket, NY
SOURCE: Hemmings
$22,450
53% below the typical asking price for a Mustang

Expand
Seller: WeBe Autos Ltd
Transmission: Manual
Color: Red
1973 Ford Mustang$34,500 · 28% below typical
27,300 miles · Automatic · Blue
Florida, NY
SOURCE: eBay
$34,500
28% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang

Expand
Seller: handw1116
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own eBay listing: Year: 1973; VIN (Vehicle Identification Number): 3F03F133335; Mileage: 27300; Body Type: Convertible; Number of Seats: 4; Transmission: Automatic; Model: Mustang; Exterior Color: Blue; Number of Doors: 2; Make: Ford; Vehicle Title: Clean. This is most likely the finest original 1973 Mustang Convertible on the market!! This is a 2 owner vehicle that has never spent a night outside of the garage and has NEVER seen rain, snow or salt!!
Color: Blue
1971 Ford Mustang$31,500 · 34% below typical
14,000 miles · Automatic · Gray
Orchard Park, NY
SOURCE: eBay
$31,500
34% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang

Expand
Seller: 546067
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own eBay listing: Year: 1971; Mileage: 14000; Interior Color: Black; Body Type: Convertible; Number of Seats: 4; Transmission: Automatic; Make: Ford; For Sale By: Private Seller; Car Type: Collector Cars; Model: Mustang; Exterior Color: Gray; Number of Doors: 2; Vehicle Title: Clean; Engine: 302. The 1971 Mustang Survivor is a classic collector car featuring a black interior, gray exterior, and a 302 engine. This convertible with automatic transmission seats 4 people and has only 14,000 miles on it.
Color: Gray
1969 Ford Mustang$18,950 · 60% below typical
30,146 miles · Manual · Metallic Green
College Point, NY
SOURCE: eBay
$18,950
60% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang

Expand
Seller: merit_cars
Transmission: Manual
Condition: Listing details from the car's own eBay listing: Year: 1969; VIN (Vehicle Identification Number): 9T03H127031; Mileage: 30146; Body Type: Convertible; Transmission: Manual; Model: Mustang; Exterior Color: Metallic Green; Make: Ford; Vehicle Title: Clean. The car has rust at the front of the floor pans, some valve noise and slight engine smoke that has been decreasing as the car is driven following a long period of storage. The existing convertible top is torn; a replacement top is included.
Color: Metallic Green
1966 Ford Mustang$20,000 · 58% below typical
60,000 miles · Automatic · Blue
Staten Island, NY
SOURCE: eBay
$20,000
58% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang

Expand
Seller: bledidiko
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own eBay listing: Year: 1966; VIN (Vehicle Identification Number): 6FO7A173392; Mileage: 60000; For Sale By: Private Seller; Body Type: Sedan; Transmission: Automatic; Model: Mustang; Exterior Color: Blue; Make: Ford; Drive Type: RWD; Vehicle Title: Clean; Engine: v6 3.7; Fuel Type: Gasoline. For sale 1966 mustang. The car is totally restored and swap 2014 v6 3.7 engine with 60.000 mi. Everything is in place but need some wiring finish. Car is being setting in my driveway since after the covid. I put so much money on this car but I am asking only $20.000. Fill free to contact me and more than welcome to see the car. I have videos and photos for everyone interested. Cell number 3477612875.
Color: Blue
1966 Ford Mustang Coupe 2D$12,500 · 44% below typical
50,000 miles · Automatic · Green
Lakewood, NY
SOURCE: Facebook
$12,500
44% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang Coupe 2D

Expand
Seller: Marketplace seller
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own Facebook Marketplace listing: Year: 1966; Mileage: 50000; Transmission: Automatic; Exterior Color: Green; Interior Color: Green.
Color: Green
1969 Ford Mustang GT 351 Convertible — Matching Numbers, Manual Transmission$17,950 · 37% below typical
Mileage not stated · manual transmission
College Point, NY
SOURCE: Dealer
$17,950
37% below the typical asking price for a Mustang GT 351 Convertible — Matching Numbers, Manual Transmission

Expand
Seller: Merit Cars
Transmission: manual transmission
Condition: Body: Convertible. Transmission: manual transmission. Interior: black.

Narrow it further