Home / Ford / Mustang Gen 1 / Automatic

Ford Mustang Gen 1 Automatic in New Jersey for sale

5 for sale now · 0 previously sold in this exact combination.

Market Snapshot

Median asking (for sale now): $18,500 (n=5)

Median sold price by quarter — all Ford Mustang Gen 1 (this combination has too few dated sales for its own trend)

$48,740$32,000$15,2602021 Q1: $34,750 (n=40)2021 Q2: $38,875 (n=42)2021 Q3: $33,250 (n=63)2021 Q4: $45,500 (n=57)2022 Q1: $45,394 (n=62)2022 Q2: $43,250 (n=66)2022 Q3: $36,950 (n=80)2022 Q4: $42,500 (n=84)2023 Q1: $34,500 (n=52)2023 Q2: $42,250 (n=60)2023 Q3: $41,000 (n=75)2023 Q4: $36,500 (n=73)2024 Q1: $38,250 (n=42)2024 Q2: $33,000 (n=74)2024 Q3: $43,000 (n=102)2024 Q4: $36,250 (n=87)2025 Q1: $35,500 (n=53)2025 Q2: $42,000 (n=96)2025 Q3: $35,425 (n=106)2025 Q4: $37,276 (n=80)2026 Q1: $38,150 (n=63)2026 Q2: $43,000 (n=113)2026 Q3: $41,000 (n=118)2026 Q4: $36,000 (n=68)2021 Q12026 Q4Median asking now: $18,500

Medians of actual prices; call-for-price cars are excluded. Sold figures use dated sales only, each labeled with its sample size.

For sale now (5)

1973 Ford Mustang Convertible$18,500 · 5% below typical
41,000 miles · Automatic · Black
Branchburg Twp, NJ
SOURCE: Facebook
$18,500
5% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang Convertible

Expand
Seller: Marketplace seller
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own Facebook Marketplace listing: Year: 1973; Mileage: 41000; Transmission: Automatic; Exterior Color: Black; Interior Color: Black.
Color: Black
1966 Ford Mustang GT Coupe 2D$8,000 · 56% below typical
100,000 miles · Automatic · Red
Sparta, NJ
SOURCE: Facebook
$8,000
56% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang GT Coupe 2D

Expand
Seller: Marketplace seller
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own Facebook Marketplace listing: Year: 1966; Mileage: 100000; Transmission: Automatic; Exterior Color: Red; Interior Color: Red.
Color: Red
1969 Ford Mustang$45,000 · 31% above typical
65,398 miles · Automatic · Red
Parsippany, NJ
SOURCE: eBay
$45,000
31% above the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang

Expand
Seller: salnic2
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own eBay listing: Year: 1969; VIN (Vehicle Identification Number): 9T03F180635; Mileage: 65398; Interior Color: Black; Previously Registered Overseas: No; Body Type: Convertible; Number of Seats: 4; Transmission: Automatic; Number of Cylinders: 8; Make: Ford; Drive Type: RWD; Fuel Type: Gasoline; For Sale By: Private Seller; Drive Side: Left-Hand Drive; Model: Mustang; Exterior Color: Red; Car Type: Classic Cars; Number of Doors: 2; Features: Air Conditioning, Cassette Player; Vehicle Title: Clean; Country of Origin: United States. see description in listing
Color: Red
1966 Ford Mustang$15,000 · 56% below typical
Mileage not stated · Automatic
Dayton, NJ
SOURCE: eBay
$15,000
56% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang

Expand
Seller: di-441423
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own eBay listing: Year: 1966; Previously Registered Overseas: No; Body Type: Convertible; Number of Seats: 4; Transmission: Automatic; Number of Cylinders: 8; Make: Ford; Service History Available: Partial; Drive Type: 2WD; Fuel Type: Gasoline; For Sale By: Private Seller; Independent Vehicle Inspection: No; Model: Mustang; Car Type: Classic Cars; Number of Doors: 2; Vehicle Title: Clean. Unfinished- restoration project
1965 Ford Mustang Convertible 2D$30,500 · 90% above typical
111,000 miles · Automatic · Yellow
Andover, NJ
SOURCE: Facebook
$30,500
90% above the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang Convertible 2D

Expand
Seller: Marketplace seller
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own Facebook Marketplace listing: Year: 1965; Mileage: 111000; Transmission: Automatic; Exterior Color: Yellow; Interior Color: White.
Color: Yellow